In short
Robinhood CEO Vlad Tenev says tokenization may have prevented the 2021 GameStop buying and selling halt, blaming outdated settlement infrastructure.
Consultants say conventional brokerages dealt with comparable surges, and Robinhood’s failure stemmed from insufficient capital reserves and threat administration.
Latest SEC steering states that tokenized belongings nonetheless require the identical collateral and settlement controls as conventional securities.
5 years after the GameStop buying and selling frenzy rocked Wall Avenue, Robinhood CEO Vlad Tenev says the episode was a “wake-up name” that uncovered deep flaws in U.S. market plumbing, and satisfied him that tokenization will be the clearest path to stopping one other such failure.
In a publish on X, marking the January 2021 meme-stock disaster, Tenev stated Robinhood and different brokerages had been “compelled to halt shopping for” of unstable shares like GameStop because of clearinghouse deposit guidelines tied to the then-two-day settlement cycle.
The outcome, he wrote, was “huge deposit necessities, buying and selling restrictions, and thousands and thousands of sad clients,” as outdated infrastructure collided with unprecedented retail buying and selling quantity.
The remarks revisit probably the most controversial moments in Robinhood’s historical past when, in late 2021, retail merchants from Reddit’s r/WallStreetBets triggered a brief squeeze in GameStop inventory (GME), sending its value from roughly $17 initially of the yr to an intraday excessive of $483.
Robinhood quickly restricted purchases of GME and different meme shares, triggering lawsuits, political backlash from lawmakers, and a high-profile Home Monetary Companies Committee listening to, the place Tenev apologized for the corporate’s dealing with of the disaster.
Tenev stated Robinhood’s advocacy helped transfer U.S. inventory settlement from T+2 to T+1, which means trades now settle in a single enterprise day, however famous delays nonetheless stretch to T+3 or T+4 round weekends.
The treatment he advocates for is tokenization, which he says permits real-time settlement and freer buying and selling, an strategy Robinhood is already rolling out in Europe with plans for twenty-four/7, DeFi-enabled inventory tokens.
“It is affordable to say that clearing and settlement guidelines performed an enormous function,” Robin Singh, CEO of crypto tax platform Koinly, advised Decrypt. “Whereas sooner settlement may assist scale back these stresses, tokenization would not take away all market or regulatory challenges.”
However critics say the settlement bottleneck solely partially explains what went flawed. Whereas the T+2 clearing cycle amplified liquidity stress through the surge, it didn’t have an effect on all brokers equally, elevating questions on whether or not Robinhood’s inside threat controls and capital planning had been ample for the size of demand it confronted.
Musheer Ahmed, founder and managing director of FinStep Asia, advised Decrypt that conventional brokerages have beforehand dealt with comparable surges in demand for inventory with out incident.
“It’s seemingly that Robinhood had not factored in capital reserves and threat administration controls for such a excessive scale of curiosity,” he stated.
“Regardless of the size and phrases for collateral, the buck stops with the dealer to have the ability to guarantee clean buying and selling for his or her shoppers always,” Ahmed added. “If a agency is unable to maintain up, then it’s a lacuna that they should work on and repair.”
Tokenization has been attracting rising curiosity, with prime executives framing it because the subsequent step within the monetary evolution.
Tokenization of shares can “doubtlessly alleviate the collateral pressures,” Ahmed stated, if there are “acceptable good contracts in place to supply the collateral in real-time.”
Nonetheless, regulatory constraints loom as on Tuesday, SEC workers reiterated that tokenized securities stay topic to present federal securities legal guidelines, which means that blockchain format alone doesn’t change an asset’s authorized standing.
“With out regulatory readability, such efforts are moot,” Tenev wrote, saying collaboration with the SEC and CLARITY-driven tokenization requirements may keep away from one other 2021-style shutdown.
Day by day Debrief E-newsletter
Begin on daily basis with the highest information tales proper now, plus unique options, a podcast, movies and extra.